Unitary Councillor Nigel White is delighted to report the following good news for Winsley residents…
The speed limit on the B3108 has been a major concern for Winsley residents for many years. Previous attempts to secure a 10mph reduction on the bypass were unsuccessful because not enough evidence could be provided to satisfy Highways’ requirements.
When I was campaigning for election last year, the issue remained the number one concern raised by residents on the doorstep. As a result, I made it one of my priorities to revisit the case and see whether a different approach could deliver a better outcome.
As residents will remember, the closure of the A36 led to a temporary reduction in speed limits on the B3108, creating what was effectively a six-month trial of lower speed limits. This presented an opportunity. Rather than simply repeating the same arguments that had failed to persuade Highways in the past, we could now ask them what evidence existed to show that the lower limits should not be made permanent. If there was no evidence of any negative impact on traffic flow, enforcement or road operation, then the views of local residents should surely carry much greater weight.
I approached Highways and, despite their best efforts, they were unable to identify any evidence that the temporary lower limits had caused problems. At the same time, Winsley Hill Traffic Action Group (WHTAG) undertook a petition and the Parish Council asked for statements of support from residents and local businesses. More than 100 responses were received, with all but three supporting the lower speed limits. The logic behind the request now seemed compelling and we submitted a case to Wiltshire Highways.
By the end of last year, progress appeared promising. However, in February, a new obstacle emerged. Highways began using a system called Connected Drive, which analyses vehicle speeds using satellite navigation data. Importantly, it also provides historical information, that allowed speeds before, during and after the six-month trial period to be compared.
Using this data, Highways concluded that the case for retaining the higher speed limits remained stronger and, in April, issued a briefing note rejecting our request. It appeared that we had reached a dead end.
Fortunately, we had not.
After considerable research, I produced an analysis of the data based on Department for Transport guidance. This showed that, during the period when the lower limits were in place, the overall road safety environment had improved significantly, challenging the conclusions that had been drawn by Highways.
There were still significant hurdles to overcome. As with previous assessments, there was insufficient collision data to meet the formal criteria for a speed limit reduction. In addition, Winsley Hill did not qualify for a 30mph limit under Department for Transport guidance, which requires at least 20 properties fronting the road within a 600-metre stretch. Winsley Hill has only 15. However marginal that shortfall may seem, it represented an insurmountable barrier.
Given those constraints, I focused on the bypass and the significant changes in the ‘road context’ since the last assessment. These included the installation of a new pedestrian crossing, the Avonpark development, and the proposed expansion of the Rugby Club. After numerous revisions and refinements, I submitted an appeal to Cllr Martin Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways.
After careful consideration, Martin decided that the arguments laid out in the appeal were robust enough for him to use his executive powers to uphold the appeal. For that, I would like to offer him my sincere thanks.
While I appreciate that some residents, including members of the WHTAG, will be disappointed not to have a reduction to 30mph on Winsley Hill, I am delighted that, after many years of campaigning, we have secured a permanent 40mph speed limit on the bypass.
The next step in the process will now be for Wiltshire Highways to undertake a Traffic Regulation Order.
This outcome would not have been possible without the support of local residents, whose voices helped make the case for change. My thanks also go to the Parish Council Highways Team, Ed Townsend and Jim Bralsford, and to our Parish Clerk, Selina Jobson, whose support throughout this process has been invaluable.